In 2011, our State Department sold out the interests of American coin collectors for no good reason when it approved new restrictions on ancient coins of Italian type in conjunction with an extension of a MOU with Italy. Unbelievably, those new Customs regulations bar entry of the exact same types of coins that are openly and legally available for sale within Italy itself.
Under that same MOU, US museums were supposed to benefit from long term loans from Italy of high-quality archaeological artifacts. Now, however, Sicily says not so fast-- it wants to renegotiate such agreements, presumably by charging high loan fees for what decides to send abroad.
CPO submits that Sicily has every right to do so, but then so too should there be a "renegotiation" of the MOU with Italy. In particular, it should be scrapped altogether or at least modified so that there are no longer any restrictions on the same types of artifacts freely available within Italy and EU itself. That would certainly include coins, but some other types of artifacts as well.
The burdens such restrictions place on Americans could never really be justified as necessary to "protect archaeological context" given such an internal market within Italy. And now, with Sicily's decision to scotch further loans, what's the remaining reasons for any MOU with the Italian National Government? None, it would seem, unless, of course, it's really always only been about suppressing the trade at the behest of the State Department's Cultural Heritage Center and its allies within the archaeological establishment.
Showing posts with label Sicily. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Sicily. Show all posts
Monday, February 10, 2014
Wednesday, November 27, 2013
More Evidence MOU with Italy is a Fraud
I heard it for myself at CPAC hearings concerning the MOU with Italy. Here was the deal as spun by the allies of the Italian Cultural Bureaucracy and the State Department Cultural Heritage Center in the Archaeological Institute of America and related groups: American collectors and museums would no longer be able to import unprovenanced artifacts. In return, the Italian Cultural Bureaucracy would allow long term loans of artifacts to American museums.
But what is the reality? Loans in fact only go to US Government institutions like the National Gallery of Art and museums that have repatriated artifacts. The good stuff only gets displayed here in the US for a short time and with substantial fees attached. And now, even this "cultural exchange" is in jeopardy as Sicily has decided to ban loans of important pieces from its own museums.
While I sympathize with Sicily and think it should get top dollar for loans, this turn of events again shows the MOU with Italy is a fraud. It is surely time for it to be scrapped. Really, what's wrong with Americans being able to import the same types of Italian artifacts collectors in Europe and indeed Italy itself have always been able to enjoy?
But what is the reality? Loans in fact only go to US Government institutions like the National Gallery of Art and museums that have repatriated artifacts. The good stuff only gets displayed here in the US for a short time and with substantial fees attached. And now, even this "cultural exchange" is in jeopardy as Sicily has decided to ban loans of important pieces from its own museums.
While I sympathize with Sicily and think it should get top dollar for loans, this turn of events again shows the MOU with Italy is a fraud. It is surely time for it to be scrapped. Really, what's wrong with Americans being able to import the same types of Italian artifacts collectors in Europe and indeed Italy itself have always been able to enjoy?
Labels:
AIA,
CPAC,
Import Restrictions,
Italian MOU,
Italy,
Museums,
Sicily
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
